A Christmas Carol Movies

After reading the book A Christmas Carol, the teacher showed us town different version of A Christmas Carol. One is the cartoon version, which was produced in 2009. The other one is from 1984 with real people staring the characters. I personally like the cartoon one more and I don't really like the old one. Because the old one was from a while ago, so the movie is kind of fake. When the ghosts come out, it is just real people hiding behind the curtains and pretend to be a ghost. But it is very fake and ludicrous. On the other side, the cartoon version is very cool and the effects are way better than the old one. But it is also bias for me to say that I like the cartoon version, because I am a fan of cartoon. So that is probably an other reason why I chose the cartoon one as my favorite.